bitcoin-dev

Adding New BIP Editors

Adding New BIP Editors

Original Postby David A. Harding

Posted on: April 1, 2024 21:13 UTC

The email in question details a selection process for candidates with potential roles within the Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIP) ecosystem, showcasing community support and individual contributions to the BIP repository.

Several names are highlighted as prospective choices for various positions, based on recommendations from different members of the Bitcoin development community. The candidates mentioned include Bryan "Kanzure" Bishop, Ruben Somsen, Jon Atack, Olaoluwa "Roasbeef" Osuntokun, Mark "Murch" Erhardt, Michael Folkson, alongside proposals for non-dev triaging by Luke Dashjr and self-nominations for the BIP editor role.

A key focus is placed on the activities of these individuals within the BIPs GitHub repository, particularly their involvement in commenting on pull requests, which serves as an indicator of their engagement and expertise. Specific statistics are provided, such as the number of total pull requests each candidate has commented on, along with a breakdown of those still open versus those closed. This data underscores the active participation of candidates like Michael Folkson, who leads with 57 comments, followed by others with varying degrees of involvement. Notably, Osuntokun's contribution extends beyond commentary, having co-authored a merged BIP, which highlights his familiarity with the procedural aspects of BIP development.

The author of the email, Dave, shares personal insights into the qualifications of the candidates, expressing a preference for Mark "Murch" Erhardt. Dave commends Murch for his extensive contributions to the Bitcoin community, including his efforts to standardize terminology through a draft BIP and his meticulous reviews of significant Bitcoin documentation. Such activities are deemed analogous to the responsibilities expected of a BIPs editor, suggesting that Murch's past endeavors have effectively prepared him for this role. This endorsement is supported by references to Murch's work on reviewing drafts of the Mastering Bitcoin book and over 200 weekly Optech newsletters, underscoring his commitment to enhancing the comprehensibility and accuracy of Bitcoin-related information.

Throughout the summary, links to various sources and discussions within the Bitcoin development community are maintained, providing readers with direct access to the conversations and contributions referenced. These links serve as valuable resources for further exploration of the topics and individuals discussed, enriching the reader's understanding of the selection process and the candidates' qualifications.